Heart’s Day

We spent much of the day perusing our inventory and sending offers to our clients who, presumably, were busy charting their day of the hearts. Well, fortunately for us, David E’s itinerary for the day included a Graileys drive by. He came in armed with a bottle of 1990 Gunther Steinmetz Kestener Paulinsberg Riesling Spatlese. Yeah, say that ten times fast. Personally, I’ll stick to “exquisite”, “phenomenal,” and “great finesse”.  Frankly, this wine had me at petrol. Definitely showing mature bouquet with petrol intermingling with honeyed apricot, peach, poached pears, roasted almonds and subtle orange blossoms. Silky-textured, elegant with a spine of acidity that was the perfect foil to its touch of honeyed sweetness. Persistent minerally finish.

Next to stop by was Louis R for a pre-dinner bottle before heading out with Julie. He had older California Cabernet in mind and I obliged with a bottle of 1987 Chappellet Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley which appeared younger than its age suggested. Pale garnet core fading to a very slight red-brick hue on the rim suggested maturity but the nose was packed with a core of deep dark plums, cassis, black cherries and hints of toasty espresso beans. After some time in the glass, there was added notes of black licorice and dried tobacco that added complexity. Resolved tannins giving supple, smooth texture. In prime drinking window right now.

The 2000 Vincent Girardin Ruchottes-Chambertin was opened next and it was showing phenomenally well with iron, minerals, dusty cherries, sweet spice and subtle smoke on the nose and palate. Delicious and succulent on the palate with vibrant acidity. Cherry-tinged finish.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Fat Tuesday

By Simon Roberts

Holy Schnikes was the phrase of the day yesterday as a slow day very quickly turned into a Graileys classic. A nice little deal was struck on a small collection of Leroy wines mid-afternoon. As part of quality control, we popped the cork on the 1993 Leroy Beaune Perrieres; it was very thin on the palate at first although it did blossom into a really interesting wine over the evening with great bouquet and tangy acidity. That said, it was up against some very hefty competition as the evening progressed.

You just never know what is going to happen here on any given day. Who knew that a rainy, dreary Tuesday in Dallas was going to be one for the books.  Dave was in town and after a pretty heavy Monday night,  a pick-me-upper was in order. Just one for the road before his flight back to Phoenix… famous last words in Graileys, just one…. And it was a magical one! Probably one of the top 10 wines opened in the last 12 months, a 2000 Leroy Romanee St Vivant! Pure liquid decadence in a bottle. Matt J sipped, I sipped, we all sipped and wow… wine in the true sense of the word. Perfumed with penetrating nose of incense, dried lavender, violet, coriander with a core of tangy red fruits (pomegranate, dried cranberry, red currant, wild berries). Full, opulent with tremendous depth and verve.

Next up was James R who promptly ordered a nice white Burgundy. A.J  obliged with a killer pull from the cellar, a 1998 Bouchard Montrachet La Cabotte. It seemed reduced initially throwing sulphury note reminiscent of a freshly struck match and gun flint. It did blow off revealing more appealing aromas of pear drop, sweet vanilla, orchard fruit, acacia, minerals and a mid-palate that was rich and dense. Well-structured with richness and fruit depth that was impressively balanced by a zippy acidity.

And just for shits and grins, James R likewise opened a 1975 Latour. Why not, it is Fat Tuesday right? Smoke, tar, charcoal and graphite notes screamed out of the bottle with a core of black fruits reminiscent of blackberries and plums. Very firmly structured with grippy tannins.

Not to be outdone,  Matt J pops open a 1983 Salon which took us all  on a whole new tangent. We thought it was showing classic oxidative character from the wine’s pale amber appearance to the aromas of hay, nuts, honey but it definitely had some energy on the palate. We wanted to love this wine so much, we kept sniffing, but we eventually cut our losses.

It does get crazy competitive here at Graileys on occasion, all in the pursuit of the best juice. This afternoon was certainly going that direction. James R suggested sharing a bottle of 1971 Dom Perignon… ha ha ha…. I just love this place and those days of stunning, crazy, full-on  Graileys. Creamy textured, rich yet elegant with very fine bubbles that caressed every inch of your palate. Packed with layers and layers of flavors -toast, biscuit, hazelnuts, brioche, oatmeal, honey, yeast. Amazing flavor intensity and a very long finish.

So, longingly glancing at the much-discussed 1983 Salon, Matt J raises the stakes again with a 1992 Dom Perignon Oenotheque Rose that blew everybody away. Seductive, delicate salmon pink in appearance. Essence of mushrooms, bread dough, biscuit, wild berries, a touch of floral and cotton candy on the nose and palate. Fleshy and creamy textured; structured; very vibrant. Still youthful but a joy to drink now nonetheless.

Lee, a member’s guest, got sucked into this circus and promptly opened a bottle of 2000 Krug Clos du Mesnil. This was definitely a baby. But the potential for greatness, at least 15 years down the road, was undeniable. Tightly-wound with a girdle of acidity that framed its structure. On the palate, it was like sucking on limestone topped with citrus peel.  Enormous mid-palate with laser-like focus. Very dry, full-bodied with complex aromas and flavors of lime blossom, chamomille, toasted hazelnuts, citrus, chalk, orchard fruit, flinty minerality… this is THE essence of Chardonnay in all its glory.

Sitting here having a laugh and indulging in this line up of wines on a dreary Tuesday  is what the good life is all about.  All of these wines changed over the course of a few hours as did the conversation. The small group that gathered and enjoyed this ever such a spontaneous tasting made for a great Tuesday. A Fat Tuesday wholly defined.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

New World Meets Old World

Wine truly brings people together who are bound by nothing but a mutual passion and appreciation for good ‘ol juice.

It was an epic night last night when both Mike Merriman, proprietor of Oregon’s Merriman Wines and Jean Trimbach, part of the current generation in-charge of the iconic Trimbach winemaking family of Alsace, both stopped in to taste us and our members on their wines.

Mike was in first with his incredibly fresh, bright fruited Pinot Noirs and his lively, succulent Chenin Blanc. Mike got into wine via the beer brewing route. He was in Oregon in 1997 to attend a Fermentation Science course when he was introduced to in-house winemaking and backyard viticulture. He caught the wine bug that he wasted no time endearing himself to the Oregon wine scene working the following year’s harvest. In eight years after that fateful trip to Oregon, he became proprietor of a vineyard in Willamette Valley. Mike produced his first vintage, four barrels of Pinot Noir, in 2006.

We have always liked Mike’s vibrant, fresh, delicate and silky Pinot Noirs but it was hard to not to be enthralled by his very good 2011 Chenin Blanc. This had pretty notes of ripe peach, pear, melon and honey comb; beautifully textured with a rich mouth-feel that was lifted by a mouth-watering acidity. The Chenin fruit are from 39-year old vines and comes from a one acre vineyard in Yakima Valley that Eric Basher, winemaker of Merriman Wines, discovered. You know that man is true to his passions when he pursues something as commercially ‘unfashionable’ as Chenin Blanc.

His second label, Cummins Road, made in that easy-drinking, juicy style packed with red fruits and a touch of sweet spice is such a great value. There are infinite ways that one can go wrong with Pinot Noir in the $25/bottle range, but this is not one of them. We tasted his 2011 Cummins Road Pinot Noir.

His 2011 Merriman Estate Pinot Noir has a darker Pinot fruit profile and more structure; supple and rounded; deep plums, cherry cola and black cherries dominate; a touch of cinnamon and clove add aromatic complexity; some grip from oak tannins on the finish.

Jean Trimbach, 12th generation member of the iconic Maison Trimbach winemaking family of Alsace, was in next. Even Mike Merriman was excited to taste through Jean’s awesome line-up of whites.

Some of the standouts included the 2003 Clos-St-Hune Riesling… a treat really with its deep impressions of flinty minerality, smoky gravel, steely, pear, honeyed, floral, apricot; very subtle petrol. Racy, focused and penetrating but more open and approachable than the 2001 and 2002 Clos-St-Hune I had the pleasure of tasting recently. I sipped every last drop of this tasty treat.

The 2005 Cuvee Frederic Emile Riesling was showing some secondary aromas with its deeply pitched petrol, musky and honeyed components with peach, apricot, nectarine and orange blossoms. Classic in its weightier, luscious texture on the palate but zippy acidity that really enlivens the wine. It will take a lot of discipline not to drink this delicious wine right now, but this has the stuffing and balance to age and develop for another 20-25 years.

The 2004 Cuvee des Seigneurs de Ribeaupierre Gewurztraminer’s flamboyant guava, lychee, pineapple, melon, honeyed peach, apricot flavor profile was very attractive. This was echoed on the bold, rich palate that was balanced by a lively acidity.

The 2009 Pinot Blanc was also very good with its green apple, pear, citrus and ginger spice. Medium-bodied, lush mid-palate with a vibrant acidity. Citrus tinge on the finish.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Silver Oak

Yesterday we tasted a vertical lineup of Silver Oak made by famed winemaker Daniel Baron. Daniel got his start in winemaking at Chateau Montelena where he worked for four years. After Chateau Montelena Daniel ended up in Bordeaux and met Jean Claude Berrouet, the winemaker at Petrus. This is what really launched Daniels carrier as he had the amazing opportunity to work with the famed 1982 vintage of Petrus.

Daniel was a wealth of information and was great at answering everyone’s questions as well as regaling us with some amazing stories.

To be paired with the wines we had Sharon Hage, former chef of York Street, cooking some absolutely delicious meals! My favorite was the veal served two ways, roasted and baked, over a white bean puree. Absolutely wonderful! Sharon really outdid herself with five courses of wonderful cuisine for the event.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Pre-Super Bowl Party

 

My Friday started with the 1993 Opus One that Mike F wanted to toast the beginning of his weekend with. Incredibly complex bouquet of forest floor, wet earth, cedar, black cherries, blackcurrant with undertones of savory, dried herbs and baking spice led to a palate that was pure elegance and refinement. Silky-textured, medium-bodied, fresh acidity that kept the wine’s finish going. Bottle age has really done this wine a lot of good developing such flavor complexity and beautiful texture that is dazzling. This is in a great drinking window now.

Keith F was in this Friday as well and didn’t waste any time in chilling a split of Krug Grande Cuvee for Jean Ann. We’ve opened many a half bottles of this fizz but this one bottle showed more toasty richness and a flavor intensity more reminiscent of a vintage Champagne. Nutty, butterscotch notes along with acacia, pear and white peach and very fine, persistent bubbles… I was in bubbly heaven.

Up next was a 1996 Bernard Dugat-Py Gevrey-Chambertin ‘Couer du Roy’ that was flamboyant and showy on the first pour. Deep minerality, spice, plums, black cherries and subtle forest floor-dried leaves notes were consistent on the nose and palate. This was a fuller-bodied, denser rendition of Pinot Noir that was drinking younger than its age suggested and certainly punching way beyond its Villages quality designation. This wine’s structure and flavor concentration further suggest its suitability for more aging.

Our resident expert on California wines, Ivan F, walked in next, arms heavy with current releases of Relic Wines. We tasted the 2010 The Prior, a blend of 80% Cabernet Franc and 20% Malbec from Napa Valley. This is very primary right now showcasing ripe and luscious black raspberries, black cherries, sweet vanilla, cocoa powder and toasty oak aromas and flavors. Rich textured and velvety mid-palate… a big wine but well-balanced. This is The Prior’s inaugural vintage and what an effort from Mike Hirby! Next up from the Relic line-up was the 2009 The Archive Cabernet Sauvignon which showed intense aromas of crème de cassis, black cherry, nutmeg, toasted oak and mocha. The flavor intensity was echoed on the broad, smooth-textured, rich palate. The well-managed, softer tannins and ripe fruit make this wine a great pop-and-pour deal and certainly offers drinking pleasure now.

DD’s 1995 Leoville Las Cases was shared around the table next. This wine’s firmer structure and subtle cedar and gravel components made this a fantastic contrast to the more seductive and hedonistic style of the Relic wines. Next to the California reds, the 1995 Las Cases was noticeably compact and burly but after half an hour in the glass, this blossomed into a magnificent wine revealing complex and richer blackcurrant notes along with coffee, cedar and licorice. Incredible flavor intensity and depth and what finish! Decant for at least an hour if you insist on drinking it now or I would revisit it in another five years.

Scott F followed up with 1990 La Dominique. I was initially impressed by the wine’s beautiful perfume (wild raspberry, tobacco, tea leaves, leather) and silken texture but this, unfortunately, fell apart as the night progressed; the fruit started fading and an overwhelming damp earth component began to take over. Hollow mid-palate, slightly thinned out finish with the acidity taking center stage.

Keith F next (generously) handed me a taste of the 2006 SQN A Shot in the Dark Syrah… blackberry/blueberry jam were the first words out of my mouth! Full-bodied with mouth-coating richness on the palate, big tannins but ripe and velvety, concentrated with gobs of blackberry, blueberry, black cherries, baking spices and cocoa.  No doubt a powerful and structured wine but kudos to Manfred Krankl whose able hands are somehow able to achieve balance in this monster! This wine is part of SQN’s Extended Barrel-Aged (EBA) program composed of dry reds aged that see about 40 months of oak aging.

The party was already in full swing and I was feeling palate fatigue from all the big reds I was drinking when Simon handed me a glass of white… nice, Simon…. This showed mature notes of almonds, butterscotch,  toasty/buttered popcorn with a touch of yellow plums and tropical fruits. On the palate, the wine was creamy and rich but with a zesty acidity that kept the wine juicy and fresh. Fragrant lime blossom note on the finish. With all that flavor intensity and concentration on the palate, I expected a bit more on the finish. A good wine nonetheless. Simon revealed this was a 1999 Williams-Selyem Chardonnay ‘Hawk Hill Vineyard’.

I noticed Simon commiserating with a few members around the bar so I sauntered over to see what was going on… a 1992 Hudelot-Noellat Romanee-St-Vivant was what was going on. As I put my nose to the glass that was handed to me, this wine just exploded with raspberries, cherries, currants, clove, floral and nutmeg. The palate was equally sumptuous with its velvety texture and lively acidity packed with that Vosne spice that is simply stunning.

Mary F followed with a stellar bottle of 1987 Joseph Drouhin Musigny which was remarkable in its freshness, complexity and elegance. High-toned red cherries, wild strawberries, red currants and hibiscus with the subtlest of sweet sage and dried mushrooms in the background. Impressively elegant on the palate, silky and vibrant. Hibiscus/red currant finish. This wine was definitely on and open for business. By the time I left, the crowd was thinning out and getting ready to get their post-Graileys party started.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Kinder Surprise

We have been knee-deep in doing inventory this week but no complaints here because when you’re putting your hands on every bottle, you invariably find orphaned ones just begging to be opened which just might rock your world. So we had a mental list going of wines we were going to try later on. A few hundred bottles and pages of spreadsheets later, our member Norman A walked in and AJ wasted no time decanting a 2002 Trimbach Clos St Hune Riesling and rightfully so… this wine was tightly-wound with razor sharp acidity and tangy salinity, it needed a lot of air. I loved this wine more for its potential than where it currently is in its life. Clos St Hune’s quality is undeniable; tremendous structure, impressive focus and intensity and unbeatable length. Layered notes of lime peel,  stony minerality, flint and chamomile dominate the nose and the very dry palate. Lime pith on the finish. I think this needs more time in bottle for the very high acid to mellow down and for the palate to open up. This is definitely an exciting bottle to watch… maybe in another five or ten years.

Simon followed up with the 1983 Trimbach Gewurztraminer ‘Cuvee des Seigneurs de Ribeaupierre, one of the orphaned bottles in the cellar, which turned out to be oxidized. The cork didn’t look good, the wine was tawny-brown with flavors of walnuts and raisins. It was flat and blowsy on the palate with a short finish. Too bad.

But Simon is not one to give up easily so he marched to the cellar and pulled another bottle from our list of orphans:  1983 Domaine Willm Gewurztraminer ‘Clos Gaensbroennel Willm’ from the grand cru vineyard of Kirchberg de Barr. This was a fully mature wine with an intense bouquet of marzipan, orange marmalade, tangerine, orange blossom, apricot jam and dried dates and a palate that was dry, luscious and rich with enough acidity to keep this wine from being cloying. This wine got me on the initial nose; simply loved that marzipan/almond paste notes. Definitely drink up now.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

1995 Louis Jadot Beaune 1er Cru ‘Clos des Ursules’

The Graileys class cafeteria was a bit quiet last Friday. I suppose most of our members were wined-out from the previous night’s simultaneous tastings of vintage First Growths in the front room and California Cabernets in the back room. Member Mary F walked in with a few cases to load in her cage. For the task at hand, she opened a bottle of 1995 Louis Jadot Clos des Ursules. This has always been one of my personal go-to red Burgs as I love this wine’s typically elegant, well-defined structure. I loved the wine’s pretty aromatics from the first pour but the palate seemed austere, muted and a bit clipped on the finish. It did open up to reveal delicate notes of hibiscus, cherries, raspberries, red currant and cranberry. A subtle touch of espresso and toasty oak added complexity. The well-defined palate was consistent with the nose, dominated by bright red fruits. This was medium-bodied with a silky texture and vigorous acidity. With time in the glass, the high-toned red fruits, elegance and finesse were typical Clos des Ursules to me but I was expecting a bit more on the finish. Drink now. The vineyard of Clos des Ursules is a seven-acre sub-plot within Beaune’s premier cru vineyard of Vignes Franches; this is a monopole plot owned by the Jadot family since 1826.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Nothing New at Graileys

By: AJ McClellan

Last night was an epic night at Graileys! We had a great tasting of California Cabernet in the back but our other members put on a show of their own in the front room…

 

In the back we did a single blind tasting for 14 of our members. We tasted 1992 Opus one, 1993 Shafer Hillside Select, 1994 Phelps Insignia, 1995 Spottswoode, and 1996 Peter Michael Les Pavots.

 

1992 Opus One – The most old world in style. Notes of fresh blue and red fruits with great minerality and subtle hints of earth and leather. This was my wine of the tasting.

1993 Shafter Hillside Select – This bottle was not showing as well as it should have. There were notes of almond and burnt rubber that were slightly off-putting, but the wine was still drinkable.

1994 Phelps Insignia – This bottle was classic in every way. Black fruit with big spice and a finish of tobacco pipe.

1995 Spottswood – A great bottle of wine. Loads of blue fruit with a spicy back and a pleasant finish of anise.

1996 Peter Michael Les Pavots – By far the biggest of the five wines and the second favorite of the group. Big black and blue fruit with liquorish and smooth cassis.

 

While we were in the back conducting the blind tasting the few members that were still in the front were putting on a impressive showing of their own…

 

1995 Pichon Lalande – A massive Pichon. You would think that after being in the bottle for 18 years this wine would have mellowed out some but it is still rather tight. Massive black fruit with tight tannins and layers of earth.

1990 Remoissenet Chambolle Musigny Les Amoureuses – This is one of the more impressive Remoissenet wines I have had recently. Bright red fruit with lovely earth and compost notes. After some time in the glass this wine really opened up and started to shine!

1964 Margaux – An interesting wine. The nose was, with no better word to describe it, decrepit. However, the palate was still lively with huge earthen notes and a forest of different woods and spices. After some time in the glass the wine improved some but not much.

1970 Haut Brion – Another wine that was slightly past its drinking window. There was still plenty of acid with subtle tannins and loads of earth. The fruit was dry and dusty and about ready to limp off into the sunset.

1979 Mouton – This bottle started off a little woody but opened up dramatically in the decanter. After almost two hours the wine was singing with great fruit notes and a lovely finish.

1989 Hait Brion – One of my all time favorite bottles of wine. This one was not quite as fresh as the Magnum we had a few months back but that is to be expected. Great black and red fruits with fresh tobacco, huge five spice, and a floral display that left you breathless. This is a bottle I could drink everyday for the rest of my life and never get tired of…

1990 Pichon Baron – A wonderful example of what Pichon Baron can do in a great vintage. This has long been my favorite bottle of Baron and last night’s wine was superb. More spice and wood than fruit in this wine but the overall balance was still there with the impressive earth notes bringing the whole thing into balance.

1997 Leroy Corton Charlemagne – When it comes to white wines this is one of the better ones you can get your hands on. Notes of honey, candied lemon, lime zest, lilies, almond, and limestone are all over this bottle with a balance mouthfeel that leaves you wanting more every time you swallow.

There were a good many other wines opened on the night with highlights including 1999 Leoville Poyferre, 2000 Monbousquet, 1998 Dominique Laurent Grand Echezeaux, 2000 Lynch Bages, and 1998 Domaine Leflaive Bienvenues Batard Montrachet. All in all it as a great night, but you know there is nothing new with that when you are in Graileys…

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Thursday Flight

This was a proper precursor to last Friday’s Members Appreciation event. The handful of members we had in were in no mood to wait until Friday to pull a good bottle to share around the table. First in to inventory his cage was Bill S whose wine of choice for the task at hand was a bottle of Krug Grande Cuvee. This bubbly is simply delicious with orchard fruit, a touch of white flowers, citrus and minerals leading to a palate that is medium-bodied, creamy-textured with refined fizz. Gotta raise my glass to a man who inventories in style – here’s to you, Bill! Next in the door was DD who is knee-deep in construction dealing with the finishing touches of his new digs. The cellar sounds cool although I expect nothing less. He makes his way to his cage in the back and just stared at his wine racks. He asked me to pick a bottle… “just not the 1982 Pichon Lalande. I heard it took months to find a replacement bottle for my last one.” I pulled the 1981 Pichon Lalande which was the embodiment of elegance. Layered bouquet of tobacco, cedar, floral, licorice and black raspberries led to a palate that was silky, vibrant with perfect harmony. This is drinking at peak now and will probably stay in this window for another five years. I just kept going back to this wine and with each sip, I come up with ‘feminine’, ‘elegant’, ‘stunning’, ‘magical’… all well-deserved. My WOTN. My man Mike M walked in next with one of his new BFFs, Mitchell. He was in a Bordeaux mood and pulled the cork on a 1990 Leoville-Las Cases which showed muscle and structure. Spicy with notes of blackcurrant, gravelly undertone and complex oak nuances (espresso beans, toasty vanilla). Firm tannins, chewy texture and tremendous flavor concentration suggest this wine is meant for the long haul (easily another two decades).

Next up on the table to share was a 1996 Cos d’Estournel courtesy of Bill. This had an intense nose of ripe cassis, blackberries, roasted coffee, Asian spice, incense and licorice. Powerful and dense on the palate with well-integrated, refined tannins with a dark, bittersweet chocolate on its long finish. With these wines in the line-up, I was hoping I prepped my palate for an onslaught of crazy wines for Friday.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

The Judgment of Graileys…

By: LA Perkel


Last Friday was one for the books. Virtually every member walked in with a bottle for the first ever Judgment of Graileys. On the occasion of our annual Members Appreciation event, we thought introducing a blind tasting competition to the evening would raise the fun factor just a couple of degrees. The idea was for members to submit an entry to Simon discreetly; there were no guidelines except pulling a bottle that one believed could win them a free year’s membership and more importantly, bragging rights for a year. The line-up was tasted double blind and only Simon knew what wines were going to be tasted with individual members only knowing what order their wine was being tasted. The wines were rated on four categories – Nose, Palate, Drinkability/Ageability, and Wow Factor. Each category carried point scores of 1-10 with the scores of the top three from individual tasters tallied at the end of the tasting to come up with the winning entry. So, as soon as the clock struck 6pm, the jury of three tasters (me, AJ, and Greg) sat down faced with a wall of brown paper bags concealing what we knew were some of the best wines in the world.

We tasted in flights of three and ended up with 29 bottles. After an hour and a half of slurping and swishing, Simon rallying us on, some members intermittently visiting the judges table and apparently some wagering was going on in the room, we picked our top three.

 

Mine were #19 (1999 Dominique Laurent Echezeaux/Dr. Ellis’ entry) which was simply on: Beautifully rounded out and textured; Spicy and floral. Tremendous length and nerve. Its structure balanced by flavor depth and fruit concentration. Impressive purity of flavors. Close second was #3 (1982 Pichon-Lalande/Kelly Alana’s entry). Flamboyant and intense on the nose with a complex notes of blackcurrant and notes of cigar box, tobacco, and cedar. Full and dense. Great richness. Undoubtedly an impressive wine but  1999 Laurent Echezeaux’ purity won me over. Although I have to say that until I tasted #19, #3 was my number one wine. My number three wine was entry #25; the (1986 Gruaud-Larose/Brian Teal’s entry) which awed me with its core of cassis fruit with secondary notes of earthy spice, smoky/roasted coffee, and leather. This was firmer in structure, chewier with more noticeable tannins than the 1982 Pichon. This to me is set-up for the long haul.

After much discussion and the final tally, it was time to declare the WOTN: 1994 Dunn Howell Mountain Cabernet Sauvignon (#21: Keith and Jean Fisher’s entry). This was in my top 5. I loved the palate on this wine; resolved tannins, smooth-textured, Bordeaux-like with mature notes of savory dried herbs, earth, cedar, roasted espresso. Congratulations, Keith! Sorry, you missed out on this epic night, Jean Ann!

Below is a list of the wines entered and their scores…

1994 Dunn Howell Mountain 108
1999 Dominique Laurent Echezeaux 105
1982 Pichon Lalande 103
1986 Gruaud Larose 102
1995 Pahlmeyer 101
2007 Sassicaia 96
1991 Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet 95
1964 Remoissenet Les Combettes 90
2000 Monbousquet 88
1997 Dunn Napa 88
2007 Bryant Family 82
2000 Pichon Baron 79
1996 Guigal La Turque 78
2008 Sea Smoke 10 78
2004 Bryant Family Cabernet 77
2001 Pride Family Reserve Cabernet 76
2008 Tony Sotor White Label Pinot Noir 73
2009 Biale Zin 73
1997 Dominus 71
1999 Gros Fere Richebourg 70
2005 Janasse CDP VV 70
2001 La Palazzetta Brunello 68
1997 Pian delle Vigne Brunello 65
2008 Pintia 65
2009 Maybach Amdenus 65
2001 Rockford Shiraz 59
1967 Inglenook Cabernet – Oxidized 22

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized