By: AJ McClellan
What started out as a light night with a few members quickly turned into a battle of Bordeaux’s as one great bottle of Bordeaux came out after another each competing for the wine of the night…
2007 Domaine Charvin Chateauneuf du Pape – Big chocolate with blueberry muffin and thick tobacco on the nose. The palate was heavy with hard tannins and notes of molasses, chewing tobacco, cedar, sandalwood, clove, and dark chocolate. With 80% Grenache, you would think this wine would be lighter in style but it is a monster in the glass. In 10 years time this will be a great wine.
2007 Bruno Clavelier Vosne Romanee 1er Aux Brulees – A great example of Burgundy, very soft on the nose with bright red fruits and underlying notes of earth and subtle spice. The palate was pure elegance with light red currants and Bing cherry followed by a touch of schist and limestone.
2006 Pape Clement – Always a pleasure. This bottle of Pape Clement was tighter than the previous bottles I have had form this vintage but it was still delicious with ripe dark fruits, spice box, notes of cedar, and a finish of plums and red flowers.
1982 Leoville Barton – Still tight after almost 30 years in the bottle. This wine was classic stinky feet with woody notes of cedar and pine. The palate had a nice balance but it was not overly complex. Subtle notes of mold growing under all of the wood with a platter of old dried red fruits set overtop…
1982 Grand Puy Lacoste – I was much more impressed with the Grand Puy Lacoste than the Leoville. The nose had a hint of smoke with ripe blueberries, and red currants. There was a touch of pine but nothing overbearing mixed with tobacco, vegetable ash, and a dollop of wet tar. The palate was complex and the finish lasting.
1985 Cos d’Estournel – Cos is a close second to Pichon Lalande as my favorite 2nd growth. It is consistently exceptional and always over delivers for the price. The ‘85 showed moist earth, ripe black fruits, and graphite on the nose with a powerful palate of smooth well developed tannins paired perfectly with a soft acidity and harmonious alcohol. Exceptional wine, perfect balance.
1979 Pichon Lalande – A great bottle of Pichon. The nose was fantastic showing classic earth notes with dried fruits and subtle spice. The palate was softer than the Cos but no less complex showing hints of leather and fruit preservative.
1963 Dows – Roasted blueberries, cranberry, blackberry, with liquorish and sandal wood. The palate was chewy with smooth tannins and a little alcohol heat. There was a faint hint of bitter nut skin on the finish.