By: AJ McClellan
1955 Cos d’Estournel – The nose was like a fresh handful of mint sandwiched between chocolate and cherries with subtle old leather and a backdrop of freshly baked brownies. Exquisite! Mind boggling notes of forest floor and old earth jumped from the glass bathing your senses in old trees covered with moss stirring quietly in the wind. The back end showed a well used cobblestone road leading to the remnants of a smoldering bonfire. The palate was one of pure silk with a slight leather note followed by tar and firewood. Amazing finish of tobacco smoke and animal fur. Unfortunately after an hour in the glass this wine started to fall off, losing its illustrious spark, and faded to an old dusty shoe box…
1961 Pichon Baron – Black liquorish with big funk, dirty wet earth, clove, star anise, cedar, and coriander up front. Black cherries followed by plums and big barnyard with notes of subtle forest floor and a very animalistic finish on the nose. The palate is very smooth with surprisingly well structured fruit for a bottle with 50 years of age on it. Smooth tannins that have had all the rough edges worn off by time. Huge spice box with a light note of steminess is on the back end. The finish was spicy hot with something that might resemble a spoonful of cinnamon or Red Hots.
1982 Cos d’Estournel – Bright red cherries with Honey Nut Cheerios and milk chocolate. There was an interesting note of melon rind and S’mores. The palate was incredibly smoother but after drinking the ‘55 and ’61, it still seemed rough by comparison. Notes of chocolate and spice box followed by smoke and leather on a long finish.
1969 Remoissenet Vosne Romanee 1er Les Malconsorts – I tried this wine last week and was not overly impressed with it, but this bottle rated an elusive 100 points when I tried it on Saturday. This is the blessing and the curse of Burgundy… The nose spilled from the glass showing an intense bramble berry, cherry cough syrup, and hot chocolate with a small thorny rose bud surrounded by soft red flowers. On the second breath the nose tempts you with more liquid chocolate, roasted blueberry pie, and amazing earth notes that end in a briar patch finish that left your mouth watering. The wine sung silky notes of brilliant bright cherry and sultry soft earth which softly caressed the palate and finished with a soft blanket of dark chocolate which tucked you neatly into a long complex finish.
1978 Remoissenet Chambertin Clos de Beze GC – An amazing wine that made a good run to keep up with the ’69, showing warm toffee, mocha, chocolate covered raisins, smoke, and some forest floor on the nose. The palate was excellent, soft as a kiss and as clean and crisp as a breath of country air. Elegant black fruits mingled with coffee beans in a cheerful dance over a cloud of delicate earth.