By: Philip Robert
Tonight we enjoyed a very informative and challenging blind tasting featuring wines from the Left bank versus Right bank. For the most part, we were able to dissect the telltale characteristics of each of the wines and place them in their appropriate geography. Here at Graileys we love tasting blind, it forces us to use our sensory receptors even more and it becomes more of an intellectual exercise than just drinking a glass of wine. Alongside the wines we enjoyed a variety of dishes, from duck sausage to 21 day dry aged sirloin with mashed potatoes topped with duck confit.
Flight 1:
89 Pichon Lalande: Tobacco, plum, peat moss and a little stinky on the nose. A touch of cassis and dark berry fruit with a nicely rounded palate. This was a little polarizing for some – they loved it or didn’t. It got so much better after having been opened for several hours.
90 Ch La Fleur de Gay: Beautiful perfume of flowers, clearly an older wine. Definitely silky on the palate, very seamless. Bit of plums, black cherry fruit and a touch of smokiness to it. I wouldn’t hesitate to pull these and be drinking them. I preferred this out of the two.
Flight 2:
01 Cos d’Estournel: I know I have had this wine before. A bigger wine flight, clearly younger. Smoky cassis and licorice with a bit of mocha coffee, tobacco and minerality with lush blackberries. Very sweet fruit and quite a bit tannic. A very nice wine.
01 Bellevue Mondotte: Incredible dense, almost impenetrable in the glass. Blueberry pie filling, smoky spicy fruit with a bit of licorice. Gorgeous floral nose that makes you want to stick your nose in the glass time and time again. I really enjoyed this wine and would love to come back to it in 10 years.
Flight 3:
83 L’Evangile: A giant in the glass even with almost 30 years of age in the bottle. The nose had a distinct mint note followed by the more classic red and blue fruits and a floral arrangement of violets and daffodils. The palate was boisterous with huge earthy notes of tilled earth and barnyard funk ending in crushed dried fruits and a hint of leather and cedar.
86 Gruaud Larose: Black fruit and a subtle earthiness to it. I kept looking for the trace of brett here that I sometimes get from GL but there was none, a very clean wine. Lots of tobacco, black cherry, strawberry and chalkiness at the finish. Dark fruit and tobacco notes on the nose. More cedar and leather notes on the palate it seems this really is a much younger wine.
Once we were finished with the formal tasting, Simon suggested we drink a 94 Petrus out of mag and how often do we get to do that? This had a lovely floral nose, think crushed and dried potpourri. More blue and black fruits attack the palate and was still dark and brooding. It really needed some time in the glass to really strut but once it found its stride it just exuded elegance. Silky and smooth really just a pretty bottle of wine.
00 Lynch Bages: Another hugely dense wine but very balanced. Crushed flowers and brambles on the nose, it just blew up in the glass after an hour. Blackberry jam and plums with loads of leather and cedar. Hedonism.
93 Colgin Herb Lamb: The third bottle of this I have had in the last week and this was much better than the last bottle. Massive blueberry and cherry, still in its prime with gorgeous silky tannins and an extremely long and dense finish.
98 Guigal La Mouline: After all of the Bordeaux and Cabs that we drank tonight it was time to go to the Rhone. This was the star of the night for me. Popped and poured this just absolutely exploded in the glass with violets and crazy bacon and meaty notes. Purple sweet fruit and so incredibly balanced, while it is dense it is so open for business I’m hardly believing it. You can’t end the evening much better than this. I don’t know what kind of magic spell is being used in the winery but LaLa’s for me deliver the best bang for the buck around. An absolutely stellar bottle of wine. WOTN for me by far.
1994 Petrus Magnum – After the tasting we all threw in for this stunning bottle. It was young for sure but after a few decants and several hours in the glass this behemoth opened up to show a luscious barnyard nose with ripe black and red fruits and fantastic earthy minerality. The palate was full and think with earth and forest floor.